My review:
I have read a few children's books from this author and picked this one from my local library because I like his books. I wish that this book could be among my tops for him but it isn't.
Pros: As a Halloween book goes, a kid wants to dress up and have fun on Halloween. His goal is to be the scariest around. So scary that he makes people fall over in fright...he even scares his Dad.
The kid goes out and succeeds in getting his candy...so much candy that he cannot even lift it and someone else has to take it home for him.
The author attempted to make this a multicultural book.
Cons: The author failed! Wow, so much wrong here. I get that this book is meant to be for children but you have to remember who you are writing for.
The kid is a black child who unfortunately is oozing with very stereotypical racism. It was absolutely appalling to read when it could have been so good. Sad!
I do see the author rewrote an updated version. I cannot say that I will read it. I give this book a "boo" for sure with a one pumpkin.
Disclosure: I obtained this book from my local library. The views here are 100% my own and may differ from yours. Note: Although I abhor this book, I will not ask my library to remove it. I do read banned books and do not like censorship. I will however, voice my concerns. This is a reminder though that authors need to be better at what they write and know their audience. ~Michelle, Reading Authors Network
Where to find the author:
ROBERT MUNSCH is Canada's bestselling author of more than sixty picture books for young readers. His irreverent tales of childhood mischief, populated by diverse characters, have been loved by generations of children and their families, who have made him Canada's bestselling and best loved author. Robert lives in Guelph, Ontario. He lives in Guelph, Ontario.
No comments:
Post a Comment